For most used buyers, the twin cam vs milwaukee eight question ends with a 2020-or-newer Milwaukee-Eight. It's smoother, runs cooler and is past its teething years. A documented 2014 to 2016 Twin Cam 103 with its tensioners addressed is still a strong buy for less money, especially for long-haul touring or if you're open to buying out of state. Now the details.
I spent years turning wrenches on both engines before I started writing about them, and I'll say up front that neither one is a lemon. Each has a short list of known weak spots, and a good used bike is simply one where somebody already dealt with them. What follows is a practical harley big twin engine comparison: the specs, the parts that wear, the years that need extra scrutiny and how the two actually feel from the saddle.
Twin Cam vs. Milwaukee-Eight: The Quick Table
| Spec | Twin Cam | Milwaukee-Eight |
|---|---|---|
| Years | 1999 to 2017 (Touring through 2016, Softail and Dyna through 2017) | 2017 Touring and Trike, 2018 Softail, current |
| Displacements | 88, 96, 103, 110 cu in | 107, 114, 117 cu in |
| Valves | 2 per cylinder, two cams | 4 per cylinder, single cam, dual plugs |
| Cooling | Air/oil; Twin-Cooled heads on some 2014+ Touring | Air/oil with oil-cooled heads; Twin-Cooled on Ultra and Limited |
| Counterbalancing | Softail B engines only; Touring and Dyna rubber-mounted | Internal balancer on all; dual balancers on Softail |
| Service interval | 5,000 mi after break-in | 5,000 mi after break-in |
| Known issues | Cam chain tensioner shoes, pre-2007 inner cam bearing, heat | Early oil pump and scavenging complaints, 2017 to 2018 recalls |
| Typical used Touring price | About $6k to $16k | About $14k to $30k+ |
The Twin Cam (1999 to 2017): Simple, Proven, With One Big Asterisk
The Twin Cam 88 replaced the Evolution in 1999 and grew into the 96 for 2007, then the 103 that became standard Touring power by 2011. CVO bikes got the 110 starting in 2007. All of them are two-valve, pushrod, air and oil cooled engines, and the parts and knowledge base around them is enormous. Any independent shop in America can work on one with its eyes closed.
The Twin Cam Cam Tensioner Problem
The twin cam cam tensioner is the thing every buyer needs to ask about. The cams are driven by chains, and those chains ride against tensioner shoes made of a plastic compound. On 1999 to 2006 engines the tensioners are spring loaded; 2007 and later bikes went hydraulic, which helped, but the shoes still wear. When they go far enough, chunks of shoe material end up in the oil pump and the chain can start chewing into the cam plate.
Plan to inspect the shoes somewhere around 35,000 to 40,000 miles, sooner on a hard-ridden or poorly maintained bike. It means pulling the cam cover, which is a few hours of shop time. The common fixes are replacing the shoes with fresh OEM parts, going to an aftermarket hydraulic tensioner conversion, or switching to gear-driven cams, which eliminates the shoes entirely. Gear drive is quieter in the wallet over the long run but needs properly matched gears to avoid whine.
On a 1999 to 2006 Twin Cam, ask whether the inner cam bearing was upgraded to a full-complement bearing during tensioner service. The original bearing was a known failure point, and a seller who can show that receipt usually took care of everything else too.
Rushmore 2014 and the Heat Question
Project Rushmore in 2014 is where Twin Cam Touring bikes got genuinely good. The High Output 103 became standard, Ultra and Limited models got Twin-Cooled heads with small radiators in the lowers, and the line picked up a hydraulic clutch, linked ABS brakes, the batwing Splitstream vent and the Boom! Box infotainment system. If phone integration matters, note that only later Boom! Box GTS units support it; see our list of motorcycles with CarPlay before assuming a 2015 has it.
Heat is the Twin Cam's other reputation. The rear cylinder sits right under your right thigh, and in summer traffic it cooks. Harley's Engine Idle Temperature Management System, introduced on 2009 Touring bikes, shuts the rear cylinder off at hot idle, which helps a bit. The flip side is that a Twin Cam feels pretty nice on a 45-degree morning, and plenty of riders who log cold weather miles don't mind it at all.
The Milwaukee-Eight (Touring 2017, Softail 2018): A Real Redesign
The Milwaukee-Eight arrived on 2017 Touring and Trike models, then went into the all-new 2018 Softail chassis, which also killed off the Dyna. The name comes from eight valves: four per cylinder, with dual spark plugs and a single cam replacing the Twin Cam's pair. It still looks like a Harley V-twin, but almost nothing inside carries over.
The internal counterbalancer is the headline. Harley says it cancels about 75 percent of primary vibration at idle, and you notice it the moment you thumb the starter. Touring engines get one balancer; Softail engines, which mount rigidly, get two. Cooling is better too. The standard heads use oil jets around the exhaust valves, and Ultra and Limited models get liquid-cooled Twin-Cooled heads. The 107 launched first, the 114 followed as an upgrade and later became standard on many models, and the 117 started in CVO bikes before spreading to the 2024 Street Glide and Road Glide.
M8 107 vs 114 vs 117
In the m8 107 vs 114 debate, the 114 is worth it if you ride two-up or carry luggage. Harley rated the Touring 107 around 111 lb-ft and the Touring 114 around 122 lb-ft, and that extra pull shows up exactly where a loaded bagger needs it, at 60 mph in sixth when you roll on to pass. Solo riders on a Softail will be perfectly happy with a 107, and the price gap on used bikes often covers a cam and tune. The 117 is the torquiest of the three, but on a used CVO you're paying mostly for paint and trim.
Milwaukee-Eight Years to Avoid (or Inspect Hard)
When people ask about milwaukee eight years to avoid, the honest answer is 2017 and early 2018. Not because every bike from that window is bad, but because first-year engines tend to collect the problems. The most discussed issue is oiling. Owners and shops reported oil pump and scavenging concerns on early engines, including oil pooling in the crankcase and blowing out the breather, along with worries about lifter and cam wear. Harley revised parts over time, and many owners installed aftermarket oil pumps and cam plates from companies like S&S and Feuling, often during a cam upgrade.
Recalls are the other thing to check. Recall 18V734000 is listed against 2017 to 2018 models, and my notes tie it to the hydraulic clutch master cylinder rather than the oil pump. Either way, the process is the same: run the VIN through NHTSA's recall lookup and ask a Harley dealer to print the service history showing completed campaigns.
- Run the VIN at NHTSA for open recalls.
- Ask a dealer for completed recall and warranty work on that VIN.
- Check whether the oil pump or cam plate was replaced, and with what parts.
- Pull the dipstick and look for milky or metallic oil, then check the air cleaner for oil residue.
- Listen at idle for ticking or rattling from the cam cover area.
An early M8 with receipts for an upgraded oil pump and cam plate can be a better buy than a later bike with no history. The paperwork matters more than the model year.
How They Actually Ride
Back-to-back tests in the motorcycle press when the M8 launched landed in the same place I did. The Milwaukee-Eight is noticeably smoother at idle, makes stronger torque below 3,000 rpm and puts much less heat on your legs. Testers generally found the six-speed shifted more cleanly, and the four-valve heads made the engine feel freer revving near the top. Several reviewers also admitted to missing a little of the Twin Cam's shake at a stoplight, which tells you how much character is wrapped up in that vibration.
My own take after riding both for years: the Twin Cam 103 feels like a tractor that loves 2,500 rpm, honest and a bit rough, and it's never boring. The M8 114 feels like it has a bigger engine than it does. On a 500-mile day the M8 sends you home less tired, full stop.
Which One to Buy: A Used Harley Touring Buyer's Guide
Here's how I'd steer friends, starting with what they actually plan to do with the bike. It's the short version of any used harley touring buyers guide worth reading.
- Tight budget: a 2014 to 2016 Twin Cam 103 Street Glide or Road King with tensioner service documented. It's the best value in Harley touring right now.
- Serious touring: a 2020 or later M8 114. You get cooler running, more torque and the bugs sorted, and if you're still choosing a bike style, read up on touring vs. adventure bikes first.
- Building one: either works. Twin Cams are cheap to buy and have decades of performance parts, while M8 cam and tune packages make big gains for the money.
- Two-up riding: M8 114 or 117, ideally with Twin-Cooled heads so your passenger isn't roasting either. Make sure both of you have proper lids; our guide to helmet certifications explains what the labels mean.
Whatever you buy, budget a few hundred dollars for fresh fluids and a baseline inspection, and if it's coming home in the fall, plan for winter motorcycle storage before the first freeze.
Find Harley Riders Before You Buy
The best pre-purchase research isn't on a forum. It comes from talking to people who own the exact bike. GarageApp's nearby owner search shows riders in your area, and make/model/trim search lets you find someone with, say, a 2017 Ultra Limited and ask what their oil pump experience was. Owners often keep service records in their Virtual Garage, and direct messaging makes it easy to ask a polite question without cornering someone at a gas station.
GarageApp's marque owner groups are another good resource, alongside your local HOG chapter; if you're not sure how those differ, here's our explainer on riding group vs. club vs. chapter. Local event discovery in the app helps you find group rides near you, where you can see both engines side by side in the parking lot. Brush up on hand signals before your first ride with a new crew.
Rallies are the best test-ride buffet in the country. Check our list of the biggest motorcycle events or browse motorcycle rallies near you, and spend an afternoon asking Twin Cam and M8 owners what they'd buy again. For more tools, see our roundup of the best motorcycle apps.
Comments (0)
Be the first to comment.
You need to be logged in to comment
Not a member yet? Join GarageApp to join the conversation.
Your comment has been sent!
Our GarageApp team will moderate your comment shortly.