Last checked: November 14, 2026
For most used buyers, the best Boxster or Cayman is a 2009 to 2012 987.2: no IMS bearing, direct injection and PDK. Buy a 986 or 987.1 only with proof the bearing was addressed. Here is how all four Porsche Boxster generations compare.
I inspect these cars for a living, and the questions I get mirror the ones people ask about every BMW M3 generation or C5 vs C6 vs C7 vs C8 Corvette shoppers: which years are safe, which are overpriced, and which one fits the money you actually have. The Boxster and the Cayman share an engine, a chassis and most of their problems, so I treat the Porsche Cayman generations right alongside the roadsters below. Any price or fact I couldn't tie to a dated source is marked.
At a Glance: Every Boxster and Cayman Generation
| Generation (years) | Engines | IMS bearing | Typical US price | My pick |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 986 (1997 to 2004) | 2.5, 2.7, 3.2 flat-six | Yes, dual or single row by year | $8K to $20K | 2000 to 2004 S with IMS retrofit |
| 987.1 (2005 to 2008) | 2.7, 3.2, 3.4 flat-six | Yes, larger non-serviceable unit | $15K to $30K | Base 2.7 or 2.9-free S with clean bore scope |
| 987.2 (2009 to 2012) | 2.9, 3.4 DFI flat-six | No | $22K to $45K | Cayman S or Boxster S, manual or PDK |
| 981 (2013 to 2016) | 2.7, 3.4, 3.8 flat-six | No | $35K to $110K+ | Cayman S or GTS |
| 718 (2017 on) | 2.0, 2.5 turbo four; 4.0 flat-six | No | $45K to $150K+ | 4.0 GTS |
What Is the Porsche 986 Boxster? (1997 to 2004)
The 986 is the car that saved Porsche, and it still drives beautifully. The 986 is the first-generation Porsche Boxster, built from 1997 to 2004 with mid-mounted flat-six engines from 2.5 to 3.2 liters. It’s the cheapest way into a mid-engine Porsche, but you should confirm the IMS bearing has been upgraded before you buy.
The bearing is the whole story here. Early cars generally used a dual-row IMS bearing, which specialists like LN Engineering consider the more durable design. Porsche switched to a single-row bearing around the 2000 to 2001 model years, and that version is the one with the reputation. The changeover wasn't clean by model year, so an engine number check is the only reliable answer.
Ask for the engine serial number before you drive across the state. An independent shop or a 986 forum can tell you which IMS bearing the car most likely left the factory with.
What Changed With the 987.1 Boxster and Cayman? (2005 to 2008)
The 987.1 gave the Boxster more power, a stiffer chassis, a better interior and sharper styling, and it introduced the Cayman coupe for the 2006 model year. It still uses the M96/M97 engines, so you need to check any used example for IMS bearing wear and bore scoring. The 2007 and 2008 Boxster S and Cayman S got a 3.4-liter engine.
Two problems overlap here. Most cars use a larger IMS bearing that can't be serviced without splitting the engine, so the common retrofit doesn't apply. The bigger-bore S engines are also known for cylinder bore scoring, which specialists such as Hartech and LN Engineering have documented on the M96 and M97 family. Scoring shows up as oil consumption, a ticking cold start or a sooty right-bank tailpipe. A bore scope settles it.
Why Is the 987.2 the Best Boxster and Cayman to Buy Used? (2009 to 2012)
The 987.2 is often called the best used buy because Porsche moved to the 9A1 direct-injection engines, 2.9 liters in the base car and 3.4 in the S, and dropped the IMS bearing entirely. PDK replaced the old Tiptronic, and that alone transforms the car for daily use. If you're torn on gearboxes, our breakdown of manual vs dual-clutch vs automatic covers the tradeoffs honestly.
The specials are the 2011 Boxster Spyder and the 2012 Cayman R, a lighter, stiffer 330-horsepower Cayman that's become a quiet collectible. Clean base cars still slip into our list of best used sports cars under $30K, which makes the 987.2 the best year Porsche Boxster to buy for most people right now.
How Is the 981 Different From the 987? (2013 to 2016)
The 981 Boxster arrived for 2013 and the Cayman for 2014. The 981 has a lighter, stiffer chassis, a longer wheelbase and electric power steering instead of hydraulic. It’s also the last generation with a naturally aspirated flat-six in every model, and the Cayman GT4 and 2016 Boxster Spyder are its standout versions.
The headliner is the 2016 Cayman GT4: a 3.8-liter flat-six, six-speed manual only, and front-end hardware borrowed from the 911 GT3. If you plan to use one properly, budget for what a track day costs before you budget for mods. GT4 prices have held up well enough that it shows up in conversations about the fastest appreciating cars under $100K.
On any 981, check the date and brand codes on all four tires. Mismatched or old rubber is the most common reason a test drive feels nervous, and owners often blame the car.
Why Did Porsche Put a Four-Cylinder in the 718? (2017-2026)
The 718 swapped the flat-six for turbocharged flat-fours: 2.0 liters in the base car and 2.5 in the S. They're quick and torquey, but the sound is flat and the character is gone. Many buyers didn’t like how they sounded, so the flat-six GTS 4.0, GT4, Spyder and GT4 RS are the models that hold their value best.
In the 718 Cayman vs 981 debate, I'd take a 981 S over any four-cylinder 718, and a 718 GTS 4.0 over any 981 except the GT4. It's a strong pick if you're shopping convertibles and roadsters for 2027 and want something still under warranty.
Boxster IMS Bearing Years and Retrofit Cost
- 1997 to roughly 2000: dual-row bearing, retrofit-eligible
- Roughly 2001 to 2005: single-row bearing, the highest-risk group and retrofit-eligible
- 2006 to 2008: larger non-serviceable bearing on most engines
- 2009 on: no IMS bearing
An IMS retrofit such as LN Engineering's is usually done alongside a clutch, since the transmission is already out. Expect roughly $2,000 to $3,500 installed at an independent shop. Paperwork matters more than promises: I want an invoice with the shop name, mileage and part number.
Boxster or Cayman?
Same platform, different personality. The Cayman's fixed roof makes it stiffer, and it has a usable rear hatch. The Boxster gives you open air, which is the point for a lot of buyers. Caymans typically command a premium over equivalent Boxsters of the same year and trim. Our take: buy the Cayman for track use, the Boxster for weekend roads. If you're cross-shopping cheaper roadsters, the Miata NA vs NB vs NC vs ND guide is a useful reality check on running costs.
Best Years and Years to Avoid
- Best overall: 2009 to 2012 987.2 Boxster S or Cayman S
- Best enthusiast buy: 2014 to 2016 981 Cayman S or GTS
- Best collectible: 2016 Cayman GT4 or 2012 Cayman R
- Approach with caution: 2001 to 2005 cars without IMS paperwork, and 2005 to 2008 S models without a bore scope
Clean, documented examples trade on auction sites constantly, and our comparison of Bring a Trailer vs Cars & Bids explains how to read those results without overpaying.
Used Porsche Cayman Buying Guide: Pre-Purchase Checks
- Book a PPI with a Porsche independent, not a general shop. Use our pre-purchase inspection checklist as a baseline.
- Pull the over-rev report from the DME. Ranges 1 and 2 are normal; repeated hits in the higher ranges suggest money shifts.
- Bore scope the cylinders on any M96 or M97 engine, especially 3.4 and 3.8 S engines.
- Check for coolant leaks at the radiators behind the front bumper and the expansion tank.
- Read the service records for IMS, clutch, water pump and coolant work.
If the car is far away, paying a local Porsche independent for a remote PPI costs less than one wasted flight. Read up on buying a car out of state before you commit.
Find Boxster and Cayman Owners Near You
The best intel on a specific car usually comes from someone who owns one. GarageApp's nearby owner search shows enthusiasts around you, and make/model/trim search lets you filter right down to 987.2 Cayman S or 981 GTS owners. Plenty of them will happily tell you which local shop did their IMS retrofit, and direct messaging makes that an easy ask.
Join a marque owner group, browse other owners' Virtual Garage builds, and use local event discovery to find a Porsche meet where you can sit in all four generations back to back. If you've never done it before, here's how to join a car club without feeling like the new guy. Once you buy, add the car to your own GarageApp Virtual Garage and keep the service history with it.
Comments (0)
Be the first to comment.
You need to be logged in to comment
Not a member yet? Join GarageApp to join the conversation.
Your comment has been sent!
Our GarageApp team will moderate your comment shortly.